Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Montana government, elections and legislative news

Supreme Court candidates differ on partisanship, constitutional interpretation

Montana Supreme Court candidates Dan Wilson (Left) and Amy Eddy (right).
Shaylee Ragar
Montana Supreme Court candidates Dan Wilson (left) and Amy Eddy (right).

Two judges from the same court are competing for a seat on the Montana Supreme Court. The justices spoke to MTPR’s Clayton Murphy about partisanship, restraint and what they would bring to the bench.

Judges Dan Wilson and Amy Eddy both serve on Montana’s 11th District Court in Flathead County.

Wilson started practicing as a lawyer in 1993, and has served as a judge since 2017. This is his second bid for a seat on the high court – he lost his first in 2024. Wilson calls himself a “constitutional conservative,” in that when the Constitution is unclear, he tries to find an answer in the original drafting of Montana’s bill of rights.

“And so when that's the case, then it's a judge's obligation, in my view, to go back into the history of the adoption of the Constitution in 1972,” Wilson says.

Judge Eddy agrees that it’s important to understand original intentions, but says she takes a more modern approach.

“We've had more than 50 years of Supreme Court decisions interpreting the Constitution, and we've had more than 50 years of the Legislature enacting statutes within that constitutional structure. Montana is unique in that our Constitution is not meant to be frozen in time,” she says.

Eddy has been serving on the bench since 2015 after running a private practice for 15 years. She also established a special claims court for people exposed to asbestos from mines in Libby.

The biggest difference between the candidates is how they’ve been campaigning.

During the 2025 legislative session, Republican leaders pushed hard in favor of turning judicial elections partisan. Most of these bills, like one that would add party affiliation next to a judge’s name on the ballot, were voted down. But a bill that allows political parties to contribute to campaigns was passed and signed by Gov. Greg Gianforte, opening the door to stronger ties between parties and judicial candidates.

Wilson is embracing that change. He was the keynote speaker at a Montana GOP event in February. The party posted to X Wednesday, “Judge Dan Wilson is the Republican candidate for Montana Supreme Court this November.” Wilson has also received almost $34,000 from the GOP and Republican central committees. 

Wilson said he takes issue with funding from political activism groups but said a political party is different.

“So special interests – you can call them what you like – but the parties have very broad interests. Other groups have very narrow interests,” he says.

Wilson has said he thinks the state’s courts have had too many “judicial activists” and judges have started leaning left. That idea is why Republicans have been pushing to make the judiciary partisan.

Eddy has been funded and supported by Democrats, including a PAC affiliated with former Democratic Sen. Max Baucus. But she’s denied partisanship. She said she’s also received donations from Republican and nonpartisan elected officials.

Eddy said she waited to announce her campaign until the session was over, because if a bill allowing partisan judicial elections passed, she would have run as an independent.

“I think it's important for people when they come to court to know regardless of their circumstances that they're getting a fair shake in front of the judge.”

Eddy said the majority of her supporters have been lawyers and other judges. But Wilson counters that’s a bad look, because if elected she would likely run into those supporters in the courtroom.

Voters will promote one of the judges on November 3.

MTPR will continue covering state elections and offer special coverage on election night, November 3, from 5 p.m. to 11 p.m.

Four candidates face-off in chaotic Senate race
The race to be Montana’s next U.S. senator is heating up in the final three weeks until election day. Recent polling shows Republican Kurt Alme has a comfortable lead in the four-way race. Meanwhile, independent Seth Bodnar and Democrat Alani Bankhead have hit the campaign trail hard trying to appeal to the same centrist and left-wing voters.
Western district House candidates say affordability is their top concern
The race for Montana’s western district House seat is tight. Recent polls show the two major candidates are tied with no clear lead. MTPR’s Clayton Murphy has this profile of the Democrat and Republican competing for the seat.
Supreme Court candidates differ on partisanship, constitutional interpretation
Two judges from the same court are competing for a seat on the Montana Supreme Court. The justices spoke to MTPR’s Clayton Murphy about partisanship, restraint and what they would bring to the bench.
CI-132: Montana voters will issue a verdict on partisan judicial elections
Montana’s judicial elections are nonpartisan. An initiative to permanently keep it that way will appear on November’s ballot. Republican state legislators have tried unsuccessfully to make judicial elections partisan during recent legislative sessions.
Republican incumbent faces three challengers to represent eastern Montana in the U.S. House
It's been more than thirty years since Montanans elected a non-GOP candidate to the U.S. House of Representatives, and this year a Democrat, an Independent and a Libertarian are betting on a change.
'Montana Plan' ballot initiative aims to end dark money spending in Montana 
Elections have consistently broken spending records in the state in recent years, largely due to corporate money. A ballot measure known as the Montana Plan aims to eliminate that kind of spending in Montana, sidestepping a controversial U.S. Supreme Court ruling. That would make the state a national legal test case.
PSC District 1 candidates campaign on energy costs, data centers and transparency
Two candidates are vying for the open District 1 seat on the Public Service Commission. This district is the biggest in the state by land and covers much of eastern Montana, from the Rocky Boy’s Reservation to Glendive and Miles City. MTPR’s Clayton Murphy speaks with Keila Szpaller, deputy editor of the Daily Montanan, about the race and what this election may mean for Montanans.
PSC District 5 race highlights competing views on the role of utility regulators 
The Public Service Commission’s District 5 seat is up for election. Voters from the Blackfeet Indian Reservation to Helena and parts of Missoula will get to choose who represents them on the board. MTPR’s Clayton Murphy talks with Deputy Editor of the Daily Montanan Keila Szpaller about who’s running and what the race could mean for voters.
Your guide the 2026 Montana elections

Clayton Murphy is MTPR's Capitol Bureau Chief. Contact Clayton at clayton.murphy@mtpr.org
Become a sustaining member for as low as $5/month
Make an annual or one-time donation to support MTPR
Pay an existing pledge or update your payment information