MTPR

Butte Reaches Superfund Milestone, Releasing Berkeley Pit Water Into Silver Bow Creek

Oct 1, 2019

This week, for the first time ever, once toxic water from the Berkeley Pit, the abandoned open pit copper mine in Butte, is being treated and released into the headwaters of the Clark Fork River.

It’s Monday afternoon and I’m standing on the banks of Silver Bow Creek in the center of Butte with Ron Halsey, an operations manager for Atlantic Richfield. We’re watching an endless rush of clear water cascade through a man-made rock wall into the stream, which is one of the headwaters of the Clark Fork River.

"Seeing the water come out of the rocks there, and having discharge to the creek has been very — the best part of the day so far," Halsey says.

He’s in high spirits because while there’s no official ribbon cutting, or pomp and circumstance, we’re witnessing a historic milestone in Butte’s Superfund cleanup.

Thirty seven years ago, Atlantic Richfield, a former oil company now owned by BP, abandoned the Berkeley Pit and allowed the former open-pit copper mine to start flooding with acidic, heavy metal laden mine water.

Now, with a greenlight from the Environmental Protection Agency, treated water from the Berkeley Pit is being released into Silver Bow Creek for the first time.

"Today we’re discharging about six million gallons per day, or about 5,000 gpm, gallons per minute," Halsey says.

That sounds like a lot, but the Berkeley Pit currently holds about 50 billion gallons of toxic water. Left to its own devices, it would keep flooding, and eventually breach the bedrock and contaminate Butte’s aquifer and creeks. 

The Berkeley pit in Butte, Montana, as seen from above.
Credit NASA (CC-BY-2)

But under Superfund, the two companies in charge of the Pit are legally required to prevent that from happening. Last year, Atlantic Richfield and Montana Resources, which owns the active copper mine next door, launched a pilot project to start managing the Pit well before it reaches that so-called “critical level”.

Ron Halsey with AR says today, "The combination of Montana Resources pumping water from the Pit, and then us treating it and discharging it, is the proof that we can actually hold the water level steady in the Pit."

Before any Berkeley Pit water reaches the creek, it travels a spaghetti like route through Montana Resources’ mining operations. First it’s pumped out of the Berkeley Pit and treated with lime. Then, water from the backside of the tailings dam is piped down to Atlantic Richfield’s new $19 million polishing plant, where it’s further treated to meet state and federal water quality standards.

Finally, Halsey says, the cleaned water is sent through a buried 24 inch pipe to a manhole on the creek bank.

"And the water comes into the manhole, where it loses a lot of its energy, before it discharges through those rocks into the creek."

Tim Hilmo, a project manager with Atlantic Richfield, says as part of the larger pilot project, the companies are going to study, "Do we have to pull 3 million gallons a day out of the Berkeley Pit to hold it steady? Do we have to pull 3.5 million gallons out of the Berkeley Pit, or 4? We don’t know. We think it’s in that range. So we’re starting today at 3 [million gallons]. As of today, we hope we’ve halted the rise of the Pit. And then as we monitor it, we’ll find out and fine tune that volume to hold the pit steady."

According to Atlantic Richfield, the water being released into the creek is continuously monitored and sampled every day. If there’s ever an issue with quality or flow, they can adjust or stop it as needed.

Hilmo says the company believes that putting clean water into the stream will have beneficial effects on the watershed.

"You know, more flow in the summer, just more flow in general. Not too much flow to where it’s problematic, but to add water to this system, we think it will make an overall healthier creek."

Hilmo says he's not aware of any potential negative impacts that adding water could have.

So far, the discharge of treated Berkeley Pit water into Silver Bow Creek has been regarded in Butte as a positive and long awaited step forward.

If everything stays on track, Atlantic Richfield plans to ramp up to 10 million gallons per day over the next few weeks.

The company is still in discussions with EPA and Montana Resources about building an additional water treatment plant to draw the level of toxic water in the Berkeley Pit down further.

CORRECTION: In an earlier version of this story, we stated that if left unmanaged, the Berkeley Pit's water would reach the "critical level" and be released into Butte's aquifer in 2023.  In fact, it is projected to reach the "critical level" or "protective level" of 5410' that year if it is left uncontrolled. But according to PitWatch, "the protective water level has a 50 ft. buffer zone before contamination is possible, making the actual contamination level 5460' above sea level." 

Related: Richest Hill - a podcast about the past, present and future of one of Americas most notorious Superfund sites in Butte, MT.