MTPR

Nations Rush Ahead With Hypersonic Weapons Amid Arms Race Fear

Oct 23, 2018
Originally published on October 23, 2018 10:29 am

President Trump's national security adviser, John Bolton, is in Moscow for a second day Tuesday, to discuss the U.S. intent to withdraw from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty. The end of the 31-year old treaty is a sign that world powers may be returning to an arms race mentality.

But it's not the only one.

Over the past year, the U.S., China and Russia have all stepped up efforts to develop a new kind of missile, a weapon that can fly faster and farther than almost anything in existence.

Known as a hypersonic weapon, it would travel at five times the speed of sound or more. It could strike at a target while evading missile defenses and hit almost without warning deep inside enemy territory.

The past year has seen a flurry of hypersonic testing. In March, Russian President Vladimir Putin announced his nation had successfully tested a hypersonic weapon known as the Kinzhal, the Russian word for dagger.

In August, China said it had conducted the first successful tests of a hypersonic prototype called Starry Sky 2. It flew for more than five minutes and reached speeds above 4,000 mph, according to state media.

These programs are just getting started, says James Acton, a physicist at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace who has studied hypersonics.

"Over the next few years we're likely to see a lot of testing," Acton says.

Last month, Mike Griffin, the Pentagon's undersecretary of defense for research and engineering, said he was worried the U.S. was losing its edge in hypersonics.

"We did the groundbreaking research. They've chosen to weaponize it. We need to respond," Griffin said at a forum on missile defense on Capitol Hill.

The U.S. is now in the process of stepping up its hypersonic research. This year, the Air Force awarded $1.4 billion in contracts to Lockheed Martin to begin working on air-launched hypersonic weapons. Other agencies, such as the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency, are also working on hypersonic weapons.

The fastest wind tunnel in town

Some of the work goes on at places like the Air Force's Wind Tunnel 9, located just outside Washington, D.C. The day I arrived to visit the tunnel, classified tests were underway. Tunnel director Dan Marren only allowed me into the atrium, where models of various missiles and spacecraft the tunnel had tested were on display.

Among the models is a sleek, silver wedge with a spine down its center.

"It's called a Waverider, which is a fancy way to say that it rides on its own shock wave," Marren says.

Here's how the Waverider works:

The wedge-shaped warhead would be put on top of a rocket and fired at enormous speeds to the very edge of space. Then, it would detach from the rocket and glide to its target. Unlike intercontinental ballistic missiles, which travel at similar speeds, the Waverider could potentially maneuver on its way down.

"This vehicle would be able to not just come from space, but be able to turn and bank and fly almost like a real airplane," Marren says.

That's the real appeal of hypersonic weapons. China and Russia are afraid the U.S. can shoot down their ballistic missiles with missile defense. A hypersonic weapon could swerve or take a round-about route to the target, while still going incredibly fast.

"You can maneuver around surface-based radars and come in and attack the gaps and seams of air and missile defenses," says Tom Karako, a missile defense expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "That's desirable to our adversaries."

There are still some big technological challenges to building these weapons.

Pushing through the air at five or six times the speed of sound generates a lot of friction. And friction means heat. At hypersonic speeds, steel turns soft like butter. The Air Force tried to build hypersonic airplanes in the 1960s. They kept melting.

But Acton says advanced materials and supercomputers are helping hypersonic development.

"We are seeing Russia, the United States and China all conducting hypersonic tests," he says. "I would be surprised if there were not hypersonic weapons deployed within the next decade."

Karako says that in many ways, hypersonic weapons are just the next generation of missiles.

"I don't think this is the sort of thing we should panic about," he says. Just as crossbows eventually led to ballistic missiles, hypersonics may simply be the next step. "This is many ways the natural order of things," Karako says.

But others see hypersonic weapons as something different. A recent study by the Rand Corp. warned that the high speeds and stealthy nature of these missiles could increase the chances of accidental war. It recommended controls on hypersonic technologies to limit their spread.

Given the potential dangers, Acton warns that the U.S. should be careful and deliberate in its development of these new weapons.

"I don't think we should develop hypersonics, just because somebody else is doing it," Acton says. "That's just an arms race."

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

President Trump's national security adviser, John Bolton, is in Moscow for a second day today. He's there to discuss President Trump's pledge to withdraw from an arms control treaty that bans certain kinds of missiles. This is one sign that world powers might be returning to an arms race mentality. Now we have another sign - efforts by the United States, China and Russia to develop a new kind of missile, a weapon that can fly faster and farther than almost anything in existence. NPR's Geoff Brumfiel has the latest.

GEOFF BRUMFIEL, BYLINE: These weapons are called hypersonic weapons. And they are fast - really fast. By definition, they travel at least five times the speed of sound, thousands of miles per hour. The Air Force is currently developing hypersonic weapons, including at a place called Wind Tunnel 9, just outside of Washington, D.C.

Good morning.

DAN MARREN: Good morning. Hi, Dan Marren.

BRUMFIEL: The morning I showed up, Dan Marren, who's in charge, said the tests they were running that day were classified. I wasn't going to get inside.

MARREN: No, not at this point.

BRUMFIEL: But I was allowed in the lobby of the wind tunnel building.

(SOUNDBITE OF DOOR OPENING)

BRUMFIEL: There, Marren showed me unclassified versions of the things they work on.

MARREN: So if you look on this table here, we have several of the shapes that we've tested in the wind tunnel.

BRUMFIEL: Among the models is a sleek, silver wedge with a spine down its center.

MARREN: It's called a Waverider. And so it's a fancy way to say it rides on its own shock wave.

BRUMFIEL: Here's how the Waverider works. The wedge-shaped warhead would be put on top of a rocket and fired at enormous speeds to the very edge of space. Then it would detach from the rocket and glide to its target. Now, big countries like the U.S., China and Russia already have weapons that can do something like this. They're called intercontinental ballistic missiles, and they can hit anywhere on the planet in minutes. But those missiles just go in a straight line from launch to target.

MARREN: This vehicle would not only be able to come from space but be able to turn and bank and fly almost like a real airplane.

BRUMFIEL: And that's the real appeal of hypersonics, especially for China and Russia. They're afraid the U.S. can shoot down their ballistic missiles with missile defense. A hypersonic weapon can swerve or take a roundabout route to the target while still going incredibly fast. It's essentially unstoppable.

(SOUNDBITE OF HYPERSONIC MISSILE)

BRUMFIEL: Back in August, China tested a hypersonic prototype that flew for more than five minutes and reached speeds above 4,000 miles per hour, according to state media. Russia, too, has been testing. At a missile defense roundtable last month, the Pentagon's head of research and development, Mike Griffin said he was worried the U.S. was losing its edge.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MIKE GRIFFIN: We did the groundbreaking research. They've chosen to weaponize it. We need to respond.

BRUMFIEL: And the Pentagon is stepping up its hypersonics research. Now, there are still some big technical challenges to building these weapons. Pushing through the air at five or six times the speed of sound generates a lot of friction, and friction means heat. At hypersonic speeds, steel turns soft, like butter. In fact, the Air Force tried to build hypersonic airplanes in the 1960s, but they kept melting.

(SOUNDBITE OF VIDEO)

UNIDENTIFIED NARRATOR: The thermal protection failed, permitting torch-like hypersonic air to incinerate parts of the ventral tail.

BRUMFIEL: That's an archival Air Force video showing how one experimental aircraft, the X-15, almost burned up during its flight. But James Acton, with the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, says advanced materials and supercomputers are helping hypersonics.

JAMES ACTON: We are seeing Russia, the United States and China all conduct hypersonic tests. Many of those tests - certainly not all of them - are being successful.

BRUMFIEL: Acton also says that hypersonic weapons pose a real threat to the U.S. military. But, he says, the solution isn't necessarily to develop our own hypersonic weapons in response.

ACTON: I don't think we should develop hypersonics just because somebody else is doing it. That's an arms race. I think we should develop hypersonics if it solves specific military problems or fills specific military needs.

BRUMFIEL: For now, the U.S. is stepping up testing. And back at Wind Tunnel 9, they're ready to start.

MARREN: Game on.

BRUMFIEL: All right, game on.

As I said, I can't see anything. But Marren has come up with a solution - I can stand out back, behind the tunnel, and record the rush of air as it moves through the system at Mach 10 - 10 times the speed of sound.

(SOUNDBITE OF HYPERSONIC MISSILE)

BRUMFIEL: So is that what Mach 10 sounds like?

MARREN: That's what Mach 10 sounds like.

BRUMFIEL: It's kind of noisy.

MARREN: (Laughter) It can be, yes.

BRUMFIEL: And with the test complete, hypersonic weapons inch a little bit closer to reality.

Geoff Brumfiel, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MASERATI'S "THE LANGUAGE) Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.